Thursday

Article #2: Siege/Battle of Vicksburg


This week, Week 2 of my Civil War research, I decided to focus on another one of the more famous and aptly labeled battles of the war: Vicksburg. Many people claim this this to be the most important battle of the Civil War, but is that so?

The article I read, "Siege of Vicksburg, 19 May-4 July 1863" by J. Rickard, begins with a short description of the Mississippi River and tells of its importance to the country. The author labels it as the, "most important commercial artery in the United States," and shows it to be a crucial part of the strategy of both the Northern and Southern armies in the 1860's. He also says that the town of Vicksburg, MS, was one of the last strongholds on the river, so no wonder it was a target for the Union forces. This article goes on to describe how Grant and the Union forces surrounded much of Vicksburg and other MS River forts and ports in the area, and also how Grant carried out the siege of the city. The siege ultimately worked; the people and forces in Vicksburg had to surrender at last after the terrible month of attack on the area. Rickard went on to explain again the importance of this gain for the Union, and the debilitating nature of the loss of Vicksburg, and the MS River, to the Confederacy. He gives all reasons for the battle and siege to be some of the most important turning points in the war.

I agree with Rickard on many points. The most important aspect, I think, of the Union army's win and capture of Vicksburg was their gaining the Mississippi River. It was so important for the Confederate war effort and Southern life in general (trade and transport, etc.), so the loss of it was critical. The MS River turning from Gray to Blue also cut the Confederacy in pieces, as Rickard said. Vicksburg was the last main grab in the Union's "Anaconda Plan", their land strategy to cut the South in 3 and completely immobilize it. The loss of the Mississippi was an isolating blow that the South could not afford. The siege and loss of Vicksburg was also a blow to Confederate moral. The city and citizens within it were basically destroyed while the siege and battle were going on. After the surrender in early July, some of the almost 30,000 soldiers who were defeated and discharged from the army (part of the surrender terms put forth by Grant) had to wander around what was left of the South in their dejected shame. How bad would be if you are taking your laundry off the line in you backyard (that has been burnt up by a recently raging battle) and a group of homeless soldiers walks past on the side of the road with a month's worth of bad news to tell you about. The battle moral of the Confederates was way down after this huge loss of momentum, and the hope for success all over the South was also.

Vicksburg was a hit to the Confederacy's chances and a big turning point for Union momentum. They got the push they needed to succeed in their future endeavors, and also completed one of their initial goals to separate the South's strengths. Vicksburg was such a strategic win for the Union and the Confederacy just couldn't recover. Rickard has it right when he says that Vicksburg was an essential effort in the Civil War. Was it the most important? I don't think so, but was it far-reaching and consequential, most definitely.
Article: Rickard, J. "Siege of Vicksburg, 19 May-4July 1863." Military History Encyclopedia Online. History of War, 18 Nov. 2006. Web. 31 Mar. 2010.
Lowery McNeal

Friday

Article #1 - Gettysburg


To start off my investigation of the most influential Civil War battles, I decided to begin with the most popular and well known of the battles: Gettysburg.

From the very beginning this article ("The Battle of Gettysburg - The Turning Point of the War" by Steven Chabotte) declares Gettysburg as the turning point of the war. The author, writes first of some of the statistics of the battle and then goes right into describing how the events unfolded. He talks about Meades's (Union leader) and Lee's (Confederate leader) preparations for the battle trying to show why the battle took place. This article then effectively gives an account of the successes and mistakes of the brutal three day battle that ensued, and ended in a most triumphant victory for the North. Chabotte establishes his reasoning for the importance of this battle by pointing to the aftermath; he talks of Lee's crushed spirit, the South's heavy losses, and the Union's momentum. The article shows that Gettysburg was the change in tides that the Union needed to gain their final unassailable edge and win the war.

Most people would probably site Gettysburg as one of the, if not the most important battle of the Civil War, and I have to say I must agree, kind of. The fact that it was the costliest battle has to count for something. Losing over 50, 000 people in three days has got to have a major impact. Gettysburg weakened both forces tremendously, but the battle was such a risk for the South, so the loss was more painful. Worst of all, the massive defeat, which Lee thought was almost entirely his fault, wounded his self esteem and outlook for future engagements greatly. Chabotte states, "Lee's conviction that his orders had resulted in the heavy casualties - casualties the Confederate troops, already outnumbered, could hardly afford - drove him to send a letter of resignation to Confederate President Jefferson Davis," showing that Lee was done; Gettysburg was the last straw for him. The resignation was not approved however, and Lee had to fight another day. The most important factor, to me, of the battle of Gettysburg has got to be the Union's momentum from here on out. The had defended their land, the path to Philadelphia and Washington D.C. (the Achilles heel of the Union) and had defeated the nearly invincible army of Northern Virginia-what could they not do now? Chabotte says that after Gettysburg the Union victory was "only a matter of time," and I think I have to agree.
Article: Chabotte, Steven. "The Battle of Gettysburg - The Turning Point of the War." Articles Base, Articles Base, 26 Aug. 2008. Web. 25 Mar. 2010.
Lowery McNeal

Followers

Background